Pikmin 4 Fans Call Switch 2 Edition a $10 Paid Downgrade
Pikmin 4 was one of the best games you could carry in a bag in 2023. A single Dandori challenge is a near-perfect commute-sized unit of play — short, replayable, and designed to be picked up and put down in ten-minute slices. Its Switch 2 Edition, which launched last Thursday with the new Dandori Academy content for a $10 upgrade fee, was supposed to make those slices sharper and smoother. Instead it’s sitting at a 1.9 user score on Metacritic against the 2023 original’s 8.9, with players reporting load times ballooning from roughly six seconds to thirty-plus and a frame rate that slid from a steady 30 to a stuttering one.
The Dandori Academy levels are drawing fire too — players describe them as repetitive and built from recycled story maps, though others argue the new enemy placements change how those spaces play. The resolution bump and the new voice-command support for Oatchi are broadly liked. But none of that offsets the core problem: this is the first Switch 2 Edition where the upgrade path is measurably worse in exactly the places handheld players notice most. Nintendo hasn’t published load-time data, acknowledged the reports, or committed to a patch.
Six Seconds to Thirty: Load Times Are a Portable Tax
On a docked console in a living room, a 30-second load is an annoyance. On a handheld, it changes the math of whether you play at all. If a scene transition eats thirty seconds and your train window is twelve minutes, you’re burning real estate on a loading bar instead of a Dandori run — and Pikmin 4’s whole structure is built around fast, repeatable cycles. Stretch the gaps between those cycles and the game’s portable rhythm collapses.
It compounds with suspend-resume, the feature that makes handheld play viable. You pause mid-level, put the console to sleep, come back twenty minutes later, and a version that aggressively reloads assets turns a two-second resume into another half-minute wait. These are player-reported figures, not Nintendo’s, and the once-brief original still does it better — which is the entire indictment here. The $10 bought a slower version of the same loop.
A Sharper Image Isn’t a Smoother Frame Rate
Higher resolution is the least valuable upgrade axis on a handheld. The Switch 2’s screen is small enough and dense enough that a cleaner image is pleasant but rarely transformative, while frame pacing is something you feel in your hands every time you nudge a Pikmin squad around a corner. Nintendo shipped the axis nobody was complaining about and left the two that matter — frame consistency and load speed — worse than they were on the original hardware.
The comparison stings because Nintendo wrote the template itself. Kirby and the Forgotten Land got substantial new content plus visible performance gains; Xenoblade Chronicles X got a lighter touch and heard about it. Pikmin 4’s edition lands on the wrong side of that ledger. Voice commands for Oatchi are a genuinely clever addition, but they’re also the one feature that’s awkward precisely where this game lives — on a bus, on a train, in a waiting room, talking to a dog-alien in public.
A Bad Upgrade on Nintendo’s Most Session-Friendly Franchise
The subreddit’s pushback is fair on one point: a 1.9 isn’t an honest score for a game that runs, and review-bombing flattens nuance. But the underlying signal is real, and it isn’t really about frame counts. Pikmin is arguably Nintendo’s most portable-minded first-party series — everything about its design assumes interrupted, bite-sized play — so a Switch 2 Edition that degrades the interruptions is a strange place to underdeliver. Fans reading it as a statement about the franchise’s priority inside Nintendo’s lineup are connecting dots the publisher hasn’t denied.
For now, the practical answer is simple: don’t spend the $10. The 2023 Switch version still plays on Switch 2 through backwards compatibility, loads faster, and holds its frame rate. Wait for a patch note before you pay for a worse copy of a great handheld game.