Skip to content

Switch eShop Charts: Smash Tops as Editions Stack the List

Handheld Spot Staff

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate released in December 2018 and it’s back on top of the Switch eShop this week — which says considerably less about Smash than it does about how Nintendo’s chart is built. Castlevania: Belmont’s Curse, last week’s leader, slides to #2, and Final Fantasy Resonance debuts in two places at once: #5 for the standard release and #8 for the Digital Deluxe Edition.

That’s the October 24 chart in a sentence. The all-games top 30 is a monument to software that refuses to age out — Minecraft at #3, Mario Kart 8 Deluxe at #6, Breath of the Wild at #20 — while the download-only top 30 reads like a different storefront entirely, with UFO 50, Nine Sols, Deltarune, and both Hollow Knight games carving out space of their own.

Two Editions, Two Slots: How the eShop Rewards the Double-Dip

The mechanics are simple and Nintendo isn’t alone in exploiting them: the eShop ranks SKUs, not games. Final Fantasy Resonance’s two entries inside the top ten mean a single release consumed two of the ten most visible positions on the store this week. Castlevania: Belmont’s Curse runs the same play further down, with the base game at #2 and the Midnight Edition at #19. Warrior Cats: Clans of the Forest does it twice over — Feral Edition at #9, standard edition at #28.

For anyone using the chart as a shopping list, that’s noise. A game sitting at #5 and #8 isn’t twice as popular as the thing at #6; it just bought two lottery tickets. The double-dip is rational on a handheld, though. A Switch owner already carrying one device has no reason to buy a game twice — so publishers fold the extras into a higher tier and price it as an upsell, and digital-only buyers take it because it’s still one purchase, one download, one icon. Nintendo has shown no appetite for collapsing editions into a single chart entry, so plan on reading past this every week.

FireRed at #10: The GBA Nostalgia Pipeline Is Still Printing Money

Pokémon FireRed sits at #10 on the all-games chart and #2 among download-only titles. LeafGreen lands at #21 and #3. Two Game Boy Advance games from 2004 are outselling Super Mario Odyssey, Skyrim, and Red Dead Redemption on a console whose owners are being pitched full-price current-generation software. Whatever wrapper Nintendo is selling them in, the demand signal is not subtle.

That’s the same demand keeping emulation handhelds in backorder queues worldwide — and the eShop version wins on friction. An emulation device asks you to source a ROM, manage your own saves, and hope the sleep mode behaves. A native re-release suspends mid-battle, resumes instantly, and syncs. For a commute or a flight, that convenience is worth paying for twice, and a meaningful number of people evidently are.

The Download-Only Chart Is the Better Discovery Tool for Portable Play

Castlevania: Belmont’s Curse leads the download-only list at #1. Super Smash Bros. Ultimate doesn’t appear in that top 30 at all — nor do Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, Animal Crossing: New Horizons, or Breath of the Wild. The two charts aren’t the same data sorted twice, which means the download-only view is the one worth watching if you want to know what’s genuinely moving rather than what’s permanently parked near the top.

Look at what’s on it: Stardew Valley at #7, UFO 50 at #8, Tunic at #9, Nine Sols at #10, Dave the Diver at #18, Hollow Knight and Silksong at #26 and #28, PowerWash Simulator at #30. Every one of those respects how a handheld actually gets used — short sessions, instant suspend, no lost progress. Compare that to a top ten where Skyrim and a 2017 Mario Kart still hold court, and the split tells you something real about which games survive contact with portable life.

Related